Are old fashioned conversations dead?

Whilst trying to de-clog my reader on Monday after my trip to London, I came across this very interesting post from one of my favourite blogs, The Reflective Muse. It’s all about social networking, and how it could quite possibly be detrimental to “real life” communication, and how some people use tools such as Facebook and Twitter to paint a complete picture of somebody when they’ve only really scratched the surface. As soon as I saw it, I knew I wanted to blog about it so here are my thoughts, and then I’d love to hear yours :)

I’ll admit; I’ll often judge people by the way they tweet or how their Facebook page looks e.g. interests, profile picture, status’. But then again, out in reality I’m the one who takes first impressions as a given. It’s a weakness of mine and often people have to do something spectacular to change my initial impression but in “real life” it’s harder to click “Unfollow” or “Remove from friends”. On Facebook and Twitter I often don’t think twice about scrubbing people off my friends list, which is slightly disturbing – it makes it easier for me not to give people a second chance but surely people deserve one?

Secondly, the social divisions on Facebook are out there for all to see. You know when you’re not included in things because you’re not invited to certain events – I’ve seen this regularly when university socials take place. I’m not one of those who makes themselves heard in class, I get on with things and concentrate on grades, rather than socialising – apparently that’s a crime. So when I go onto Facebook and half my class have accepted an event invitation to the “End of year social” and I haven’t even seen a sniff of an invite, the divisions become apparent. Inside jokes are also constantly entering my feed, confusing me, and then making me realise I don’t get it because I wasn’t there. Sure, these happen offline but you can turn a blind eye; with Facebook it’s hard to ignore these little snippets taking over your feed.

But, there are positives surely? I love how you can reconnect with people or even connect for that matter. I have met most of my closest, and dearest, friends online – granted, it wasn’t via Facebook but we got to know each other on message boards and over MSN. As time went on we recognised that we all have flaws that don’t show up in an instant message but it’s nice to know such a strong bond can form much quicker than it can offline. I have also been in touch with old friends on Facebook which triggered things offline – my singing teacher just recently stepped into the Facebook world and now we’re catching up with all the months we’ve not seen each other.

Going on to Twitter, you are also able to converse with people you wouldn’t normally dream of chatting to. You can get involved in heated debates and make an impact, if only small, on certain things. I remember a few months back a much loved UK singer died and a certain journalist wrote some disgusting comments in her column about how being gay killed him, and it was bound to happen sooner rather than later. Without Twitter I wouldn’t have known about this, nor would I have complained to the press complaints commission to air my views. I felt like I had a voice, and there was a large number of people on Twitter who felt the same – we were standing up for what we felt was right, and it felt good.

So, social networking can have negative impacts on communication but I make sure I have regular phone conversations with friends, and go see them when I’m free. We need to be responsible for realising that while social networking can be incredibly useful, it’s a tool – it’s not the solution. And while I step down from my soapbox, tell me what your views are.

Another interesting post about the same topic can be found at Campus Intel.

Comments
4 Responses to “Are old fashioned conversations dead?”
  1. This is a prime example of the message I wanted to express about social networking. You’ve hit the proverbial nail on the head. Thanks for visiting the website and I’m glad that what I’m writing is useful. The last few lines were a perfect example of what people have ignored for so long ‘it’s a tool – it’s not the solution’.
    .-= Ian Caithness´s last blog ..Microsoft Courier: Apple’s Competition =-.

  2. I think the uses of social networking differ for different ages. For example, I RARELY get invited to things through Facebook. And I NEVER pay attention to what my friends are invited to and what they aren’t. In fact, I put very little information about myself on Facebook. Instead, I prefer to use it, like you suggested, as a way to reconnect with old friends. And pretty much nothing more.

    I very purposefully don’t have a Twitter account because I just think it’s too much. That tells you a lot about the person I am. =)

  3. Susie Q says:

    Gosh, I’m so behind on my Reader.. :P I’ve been meaning to comment on this for aaaages but never seemed to have anything to say. There’s nothing but sawdust floating about inside my scull, I tell you!

    I think this new social media is in fact expanding our ways of communication. But not necessarily in a good way. I mean, people can communicate more freely but it also leaves out the very-important details of face-to-face communication like body language, facial expressions etc which means it’s a lot easier to be misunderstood.

    The thing I like most as well as absolutely hate is oversharing. People tend to think “well, this is my own little corner of the universe, I can say what I want here” and they don’t realise that everybody can actually see that. And that’s when all hell breaks loose. I mean, I had my mom on Facebook and uploaded photos of me smoking and drinking at the stripclub.. Not necessarily the best thing! :D

    I no longer use Facebook that much, and I’ve never really got into the whole Twitter thing. Like Nilda said, it might be an age thing. I’ve cut my Facebook down to just the bare necessities information-wise, cut down on the pictures and restricted access to my pictures, info etc. The only thing I can’t control is what my friends write on my wall and what pictures they tag of me. And that’s not what I like, considering that potential employers are now checking social media before hiring….

    Like yourself and Nilsa, I use FB mostly to connect with people from “my past”. Because they are thousands of miles away, keeping tabs the normal way is a lot more difficult. Twitter I use with my blogging buddies and then there’s the odd linkedIn-connection for professional purposes. Like you said, it’s a tool, not a solution. Like a hammer, it can help you but use it wrong and you might get seriously hurt.

    xx
    .-= Susie Q´s last blog ..I need a slap on the wrist… =-.

  4. Susie Q says:

    Apparently I like writing long comments. It’s like the bloody War and Peace!!!

    xx
    .-= Susie Q´s last blog ..I need a slap on the wrist… =-.

Leave A Comment

  • Filing cabinet

  • Previously…

  • Toolbox

  • Sisterhoods